Evie s wealthy parents have just given her an ultimatum: stop dating her boyfriend Ben, or lose their financial support her junior year of college. Worse, they want her to consider an arranged marriage to the family lawyer, Eli Wheatly. True, Eli is handsome tall, with a mop of curly black hair but looks aren't enough for Evie. She dreams of true love.
When Evie and Ben hatch a scheme to continue quietly dating while she goes out on a few dates with Eli to keep her parents happy, Evie is surprised and confused by the romantic flutterings she feels around Eli. What if she's found the man she truly loves ... while dating another?