Miriam Yoder is living a happy life as the beloved school teacher in the small Clarita, Oklahoma Amish community having accepted the fact that she will likely never marry. But when a local freelance reporter enters her world, Miriam is astonished to find herself attracted to the handsome Englisha man.
Widower Mose Stoll arrives from Miriam’s home community of Possum Valley, Ohio, in search of a second frau. Mose has spoken with Miriam’s father and is ready to meet Miriam in person. If he finds no serious flaw in Miriam, Mose plans to marry her and take her back home to Possum Valley.
When Miriam follows her heart instead of her head, she finds herself facing excommunication. Suddenly her happy life has been turned upside down with no possible solution … unless God intervenes.