Anna Beiler returns to the Pleasant Valley Amish after living for three years in the English world, but she doesn’t come back alone–she comes with a baby daughter, and she’s seeking to hide herself among the Plain People. Samuel Fisher had his own fling on the outside before coming home to take up his life among the Amish again. As someone who has been through it, he has an understanding of Anna, but she’s also a reminder of the doubts he’s never resolved. Can these two rebels find their way to God’s will for their lives, especially if that will includes each other?