Sarah MacIntosh has an identical twin who is a true sister of the heart. Quickly forging a close bond after a lifetime of separation, the twenty-five-year-olds share a dream of converting an abandoned theater called The Nevermore into a mini-mall where they can display their artistic wares.

But their project is brought to a halt by a horrifying string of events. Sarah calls on Nick, a contractor bidding on The Nevermore, for help. When the pair investigates, they are pulled into a riptide that reveals a shocking secret about the quiet Oregon community of Julesburg.