With her first two books eagerly hailed by critics as thoughtful, powerful, and entertaining
—and with strong sales to match their enthusiasm—Karen Witemeyer continues to make
her mark on inspirational fiction. Enjoyed by fans of Cathy Marie Hake, Deeanne Gist, and
Tamera Alexander, Witemeyer’s books are quickly becoming must-reads for lovers of
Christian historical romance.
Showcasing a delightful blend of humor, history, and romance,
To Win Her Heart sets a
blacksmith with a criminal past against a librarian with pacifist ideals in 1880s Texas. Drawn
together by a love of literature, do the two have a fighting chance at finding love?
1. What inspired you to write To Win Her Heart?
Have you ever wished there was an epilogue to Jesus’ parable of the Prodigal Son? I have.
When I decided to write To Win Her Heart, one question prompted the plot
development: What happens after the father welcomes the prodigal son home? So often
we focus on the wonderful homecoming the lost son received, but have you ever asked
what life was like for him after the celebration was over? How did he relate to his bitter
older brother or the servants and townspeople who were only too aware of his past
arrogance and wild living? My story plays on those very questions.
2. How did this inspiration lead to the development of your characters?
First, I needed a prodigal. Enter my hero, Levi Grant. Raised by godly parents, he turns
his back on his faith and the blacksmithing trade of his father to prove his manhood and
earn easy money through the wild life of a bare-knuckle brawler—until the day
something goes terribly wrong and he ends up in Huntsville state prison serving a two-
year sentence. Through the traumatic abuse he suffers in the labor camps combined
with the compassion he receives from the prison chaplain, Levi comes to a place of
repentance and rededicates his life to the Lord.
Our heroine, Eden Spencer, fulfills the role of the parable’s older brother character. She
has been disappointed by men in the past and has little tolerance of those who don’t
meet her high standards. She cannot abide violence of any kind and believes that
elevating young minds through education and exposure to literature will help create a
more civilized society. To this purpose, she opens a lending library in her home.
In an effort to make a clean start, Levi hides his past, and Eden believes she has finally
found a man of honor and integrity, a man worthy of the love her battered heart so
wants to give. But when the truth about his prodigal past comes to light, our tarnished
hero must fight to win back the librarian’s affections.
3. In your research, did you uncover any historical events or information that helped
shape your story?
In researching stone quarries, I ran across a tidbit that played a key role in
determining time period and setting for my book. In 1881, the Texas state capitol
building was destroyed by fire, and the Texas Legislature decided that when they rebuilt,
they would use only materials native to the state. They initially chose limestone, as there
was a quarry near Austin, but when iron particles in the rock led to discoloration, they
elected red granite instead. The granite was obtained from Granite Mountain in 1885,
and to cut costs, the state contracted convict labor for breaking the stone. The use of
free—or almost free—convict labor in the quarry, however, was seen as an attempt by
the state to undermine union labor and was opposed by virtually every organized labor
group in Austin. Hence, word spread throughout the region about the controversial
This historical event allowed me to supply my hero with quarry experience during his incarceration, but with a
project that was so well known for using convict labor, that it could easily expose his past should anyone learn of
his involvement. I couldn’t have asked for a more perfect scenario.
4. Are there elements of your own personality that influenced your characters?
I incorporated my love of fiction into both my main characters. Levi accidentally develops a love of literature
when he takes a teacher’s advice to expand his vocabulary through reading in order to mask his tendency to lisp.
Eden, on the other hand, grows to love books because of her relationship with her father. The two of them would
often pass an evening discussing plots, themes, and social ramifications of the books they read. It was a tradition
I’ve loved to read my whole life, and part of the appeal was the pleasure I found in imagining myself to be
someone else—someone daring, outspoken, and beautiful—instead of the shy, nerdy girl who would rather eat
spinach than talk to someone she didn’t know. And like Eden’s time with her father, I experienced a similar sharing
with my dad, although it was with music instead of books. Dad and I would sit and sing hymns together on the
Sunday mornings he was scheduled to lead singing at our church. I loved those mornings. They helped shape who
I grew to be. And since I married a man who loves music and leads singing, I followed Eden’s pattern by falling in
love with a man who can share the same things with me that I shared with my father.
5. What is the take-away message you want readers to receive after reading To Win Her Heart?
The underlying theme of this book is one of forgiveness and of learning to view others through God’s lens instead
of our own. Just as Jesus encouraged the Pharisees to only cast a stone if they were without sin, we must learn to
set aside our self-righteous pride in favor of mercy and forgiveness. It is human nature to keep records of wrongs
and to view others through our own hurts and prejudices. And while our God is certainly concerned with justice,
when one of his children repents, his mercy and forgiveness know no bounds. We must learn to exhibit the same
grace to our brothers and sisters in Christ, extending them the mercy we ourselves would wish to receive. After all,
love keeps no record of wrongs.
Above all, love each other deeply, because love covers over a multitude of sins. (1 Peter 4:8)